Movement One · The Colony
Chapter 2
What the Ants Are Doing
At dawn in the Chihuahuan Desert, before the sun has cleared the ridgeline, a harvester ant colony is already awake. The temperature on the sand is still bearable — perhaps twenty degrees Celsius, climbing fast. The nest entrance is a hole the width of a thumb, surrounded by a cleared disc of bare ground a meter or so across, swept of debris by the ants themselves over many days. Nothing moves at the entrance for a while. Then a few ants come up, hesitate at the rim, and go out.
These are patrollers, and they always go first.
Watch what they do, and what the colony does in response, and the day unfolds with a logic that has no author.
The patrollers spread out across the foraging area in the directions the colony's foragers will later take. There are not many of them — a few dozen, in a colony of perhaps ten thousand. They move over the ground, antennae down, and then they come back. A patroller that goes out and meets trouble — a predator, a competing colony's workers, a stretch of ground that is too hot — does not come back, or comes back slowly. A patroller that finds the way clear comes back promptly.
The species here is the red harvester, Pogonomyrmex barbatus. A colony of this kind takes about five years to mature, and once mature it can live fifteen to twenty more, the whole arc of it resting on a single queen who mated once, on a single nuptial flight, and stored enough sperm that morning to lay eggs for the next two decades. Most of what the colony is, the observer never sees. What surfaces at dawn is the thin outer edge of it.
The foragers do not leave the nest until the patrollers return.
Deborah Gordon spent decades establishing this, in a study population near Rodeo, New Mexico, that has been observed continuously since 1985. The foragers wait underground. The foraging day does not begin on a schedule, and it does not begin on a command. It begins when patrollers come back into the nest in sufficient numbers. A forager that has been touched, in the dark of the corridor, by enough returning patrollers in a short enough time begins to leave. If the patrollers do not return — if Gordon removed them with forceps as they came up, which she did — the foragers stay home.
The food is out there. The foragers are willing. But without the returning patrollers, the colony does not send them.
No ant decided this. The patrollers tested the ground by walking on it and surviving the walk. Their return is the assessment.
There is an order to the morning, too, that no one set. The nest-maintenance workers come up first, in the dim cool. Then the patrollers. Only then the foragers. Each group's activity helps trigger the next. The day assembles itself, the way a line of dominoes is not a plan but still falls in order.
The sun is higher now. The patrollers have come back. Foraging has begun.
A harvester ant colony eats seeds. The desert scatters them unevenly. The colony's problem, every morning, is to find the seeds and bring them home before the heat makes the surface lethal, which it will, by late morning, when the sand passes sixty degrees and an ant caught in the open cooks in minutes. It cannot afford to send everyone everywhere.
A forager out on the surface is losing water with every minute. Send too many out on a poor morning and the colony burns more than it brings home. Send too few on a good morning and the seeds go ungathered. The colony is running, every morning, a calculation about whether the desert is worth the water, and it runs it as a rate of contact at a door. The economics are real. The arithmetic is nowhere.
So watch a single forager. It leaves the nest along one of several trails and travels out, sometimes ten or fifteen meters, which for an animal a few millimeters long is the equivalent of a person walking several kilometers. It searches, casting about, doubling back, keeping its bearings off the angle of the sun. When it finds a seed it carries it home in a path far straighter than the wandering search that found it. When it gets home it goes inside, drops the seed, and waits.
Then it goes out again. But not immediately.
A forager that has just returned waits inside the nest before going out for its next trip. How long it waits depends on one thing: how quickly other foragers are coming back. If returning foragers are streaming in — antenna brushing antenna in the entrance chamber, contact after contact in quick succession — a waiting forager leaves again soon. If returns have slowed, it waits longer. It may not go out at all.
Gordon measured this directly. She would drop extra foragers near the entrance to raise the rate of returns, and watch outgoing traffic climb. She would intercept returning foragers to lower the rate, and watch outgoing traffic fall. In one version of the experiment she replaced the returning foragers with tiny glass beads coated in the colony's own scent and dropped them into the entrance at controlled intervals; the colony sent out foragers in response to the beads, as if the beads were sisters coming home. The rate at which foragers leave the nest is set by the rate at which foragers come back.
A returning forager that meets the next incoming forager within something like ten seconds is likely to head out again soon. Stretch the gap to half a minute and it tends to stay. The ant is holding, in its quarter-million neurons, something like a brief running average of how recently it was last touched, and acting when that average crosses a line. The line differs from ant to ant.
A forager comes back faster when food is close and plentiful, and slower when food is scarce or far. So a high rate of returns means the foraging is going well, and the colony sends more ants out. A low rate means the patch has been picked clean, and the colony eases off. The colony tunes its entire foraging force to the productivity of the desert that morning, without any ant knowing the productivity of the desert that morning. Each ant knows only how often it has been touched.
There is no forager in charge of foraging. There is no count kept anywhere of how many ants are out. The number foraging at any moment is a quantity the colony regulates and that no single ant represents. It lives in the rate of contact in a dark chamber.
The harvester does most of this without laying much of a chemical trail at all; it runs largely on contact, ant against ant, at the door. Other species lean harder on the chemistry: a forager that finds a rich food source lays a chemical mark on the way home, and other ants follow the mark out. When the source runs dry the returning ants stop marking it, and the trail fades within minutes. Researchers have set out two feeders of unequal richness and watched a colony, with no individual comparing them, concentrate almost entirely on the better one within the hour. Success reinforces the path that produced it. Failure is the absence of reinforcement, and the path fades.
Now disturb it.
This is where the colony shows what it is. The desert does not leave colonies undisturbed. A horned lizard sits by an entrance and eats foragers one after another. A researcher, deliberately, makes a mess.
In one kind of experiment, the disturbance is a mess near the nest entrance that the colony must clear — a scattering of toothpicks, a barrier of debris. Within a stretch of minutes to an hour or two, the allocation shifts. Foragers become nest workers. No manager notices the mess and reassigns the staff. The mess changes the pattern of encounters each ant experiences near the entrance, and the changed encounters change what each ant does next.
An ant that keeps meeting other ants carrying debris, in a place where debris needs carrying, takes up carrying debris. Gordon watched the four outdoor tasks — foraging, patrolling, nest maintenance, refuse work — bleed into one another. The groups are pools that drain toward wherever the encounters say the work has gone. An ant moved from foraging to maintenance was not reassigned. It met a different pattern of ants at the entrance, and the different pattern is the instruction.
When a patch the colony depended on is suddenly raided and emptied, the foragers working that direction come home slow and empty, and over the following hours the colony's effort drains away from the dead patch and pools toward the directions still paying off. Nobody redistributed it. There is no delay for a decision to be reached, because there is no point at which a decision is reached.
The colony does not respond the same way every time. A colony that has been through a stretch of hard mornings grows more conservative, slower to pour foragers out onto uncertain ground. None of the ants remember the hard mornings; ants live about a year and many of those present did not witness the earlier trouble. What carries the memory is the worn or unworn trails, the standing population, the prevailing rhythm of contact the colony has settled into. The disturbance leaves a mark on how the colony will behave tomorrow.
Out at its edges the colony does one more thing, which looks the most like negotiation and contains the least.
A mature harvester colony holds a foraging territory, and its neighbors hold theirs, and the boundaries between them are stable, often, for years. But no ant has ever walked the perimeter of the territory. No ant carries a map. Where foragers from two colonies meet, each tends to turn back toward home. Each colony's foragers, responding only to whom they bump into, settle collectively onto a line that neither colony drew.
The strangeness is recognized by smell. An ant wears its colony's identity on its body — a blend of waxy compounds on its shell, slightly different in every colony. When two foragers' antennae touch, each reads the other's blend in an instant. Nestmate: carry on. Stranger: a different reaction entirely.
A neighbor weakens, sends out fewer foragers, and the line drifts toward it. A neighbor grows and the line drifts back. The map exists. It is accurate, it is current, and it is written nowhere that any single ant could ever read.
A harvester ant carries on the order of a quarter of a million neurons, in a brain that occupies a fraction of a cubic millimeter. It cannot count. It has no representation of the colony, no concept of the territory it helps defend. It can move. It can carry. It can detect the brush of another ant, and keep a rough running sense of how often that brush has been happening lately. When the rate of contact crosses a threshold, the ant changes what it is doing. That is most of the ant.
Take one of these ants out of the colony and put it alone on a patch of clean sand, and it does almost nothing worth the name. It walks. The rules inside it are rules about other ants, and with no other ants the rules have nothing to act on. The single ant is a component with its inputs cut.
And yet, stacked up — ten thousand of these, several thousand trips a day — they produce a system that decides when the desert is safe to enter, matches its labor to the food available hour by hour, and holds a stable border with its neighbors across years. Engineers are paid well to solve versions of these problems. The colony solves them with no part of it understanding any of them.
It is tempting, watching this, to look harder at the ant — to assume the cleverness must be in there somewhere. But the harder one looks at the ant, the simpler it gets. The deciding is done somewhere else — in the rate of contact in a corridor, in the chemistry fading on a trail, in the pattern of who meets whom at the edge of the world. The ants supply the labor and the touches. The substrate supplies the intelligence.
None of these decisions were learned by any ant, and none were designed by any ant, but they were shaped, over a great deal of time. A colony that reads the morning badly brings home fewer seeds, raises fewer young, sends out fewer new queens on the nuptial flights of later years. The thresholds inside the ants are inherited; the daughters of a well-tuned colony tend to be tuned the same way. Over generations the desert keeps the settings that work and discards the ones that do not. What is on display this morning is the residue of a very long run of mornings, most of which ended in colonies that no longer exist.
By late morning the surface has become an oven. The rate of returning foragers, which set the whole machine in motion at dawn, has been falling for an hour, and as it falls the outgoing traffic falls with it. The ones outside finish their trips and come home and are not replaced. The trails, no longer walked, begin to fade in the heat. By the hottest part of the afternoon the cleared disc around the entrance is empty. The colony has pulled itself inside because the conditions that sent it out have reversed.
At dusk the entrance goes still. Deep in the nest the queen lays eggs she has been laying all day. She did not order the morning's foraging or learn of its outcome; she is the colony's ovary, not its head.
The colony has eaten. It has lost a few foragers to the lizard and the heat, and made a few more in the brood chambers to replace them. Every one of the day's decisions was real, and not one of them was made by anyone. It has held its ground.
Tomorrow the patrollers go out first, and it happens again.